Fiction · Horror
From Penned: September 2026Winner
The Promise
By Temitayo Michael · 17 min read
Not rated yet · 13 reads
The dog that would get lost would never hear the hunter’s whistle. So goes one of my dad’s favourite sayings. My response is usually that the hunter should take responsibility for making sure that his dog’s ears are sharp to his whistle. He would then smile and joke about how untrainable my ears are.
He was not smiling or joking when he called me on a Sunday afternoon, just after I came back from church. Even while he asked if I went to church and what time I got back, his voice sounded uncharacteristically stern.
“Simi,” he called my name, then paused. My heart chilled for a second. “I had a dream that has troubled me since last night. I’ve prayed about it at church, and I feel directed to warn you. Don’t go to a party, event or hangout anytime soon. You have to promise me, and remember that in our family we always keep our promises. I won’t lose you untimely.”
“Amen,” I answered. He prayed for me before dropping the call, but it still troubled my waking hours for days after.
Three months later, it was still the first thing that came to my mind when Emmy, our class socialite and the most popular guy in the department, brought up the idea on the class group chat that we should all go on a hangout just before our final papers began. I had fun reading through the different ideas and suggestions people brought up, as well as the disagreements, but I already knew I was not going. I was wistful, though; the infighting we had had since our first year had always been annoying, but now that everything was almost over, I would not mind a year or three more of all the chaos.
Jennifer, my best friend in school, privately messaged me about the hangout. I love her to bits, but she’s such a social bird, and that stresses me out because I usually prefer to keep my own company or that of a few people I am cool with. I did not have to ask to know that she would be down for wherever they decided to go, and I was stuck on how to explain to her that she would have to go alone, so I decided to respond later, switched off my data, and took a nap.
When I woke up and came back online, there was already a decision in the group chat: a picnic at Olumo Rock. Everyone was buzzing about the bonding the travel would encourage and how fitting it was to have our last fun time together as History undergrads at a historical monument. Their excitement was infectious until I remembered that Olumo Rock was in Abeokuta, my town of origin, which I had never been to, and from there, my train of thought naturally flowed back to my dad’s warning call. It would have been nice to go to my dad’s elusive town of origin, I thought, but not this time, I guess.
Just then, Emmy tagged me on the group chat.
“@Simi, you’ve been reading group messages all day, but you haven’t said anything. Aren’t you with us?”
While I was reeling from the public callout, I got stabbed from behind. “She probably doesn’t want to go with us. A proud girl and more,” Jennifer typed.
I was thinking about how to repay my Brutus in kind, but my inquisition wasn’t over, and my phone chimed again. The message read: “I don’t believe that. I’ve always seen her as a cool girl. She must be there to make memories together; there wouldn’t be another opportunity for us.”
I froze. It was Darrel. Handsome, quiet Darrel. The Darrel that I had gushed over since the second year and had had several conversations about with Jennifer. The Darrel I had never spoken to because he was so reserved that he never spoke to anyone in class, and I was too shy to walk up to him to strike up a conversation. If he snubbed me, I would not be able to live with myself, and hell hath no fury like a Simi scorned.
That same Darrel talking about an opportunity for “us” to make memories? Granted, the “us” could be the collective us, but I doubted it. It had a personal feel.
My dad says the matters of love are like a tribulation. I felt like I was in a haze; I could see notifications from the group chat that Jennifer had replied to, and the general conversation had also picked up, but I was not reading anymore.
Three days later, I paid for the picnic.
The journey was eventful. We rented the school’s 35-seater bus to take us to Olumo Rock, the historic granite mountain that served as the natural fortress of the Egba people during the 19th-century Yoruba intertribal wars. Being an Egba indigene who had never been to Abeokuta, I was so fascinated that I tried to take in the sprawling sight as we entered the town and made our way to Olumo Rock.
The icing on the cake was that Darrel was sitting right beside me. We had linked up at the park and struck up a conversation while we waited for our tardy classmates, whose deep sense of “African timing” would never allow them to be anywhere on time.
It was pleasantries at first, and just that had made me feel giddy, but over the journey, it just kept getting better. He was intelligent and had a historian’s depth and a narrator’s voice. We were all familiar with the story of the Egba people due to coursework, but he narrated the story of the Egba wars and the discovery of Olumo Rock with so much depth and detail that it took most of the journey to tell. He spoke about Lisabi, the hero who fought for Egba independence, with so much passion that it was infectious. He also mentioned Adagba, who first discovered Olumo Rock, as well as Ogundipe and Sodeke, who were early military leaders who organised the settlement around Olumo Rock.
The storytelling brought me closer to my homeland and made the whole experience twice the fun. Jennifer sat sullenly at my left-hand side because her best friend could not be bothered to put together a three-consecutive-sentence conversation with her all through the journey, but I scarcely noticed because of how engrossed I was.
When we finally got off at the gate of Olumo Rock, I was experiencing a confluence of emotions—happy, emotional and stressed, with a tiny slice of guilt. I tried to hug Jennifer, but she turned her back to me. I still hugged her back, though, and made a mental note to apologise later.
I looked around for my Prince Charming, but he had moved forward. I noticed then that everyone had moved forward; there seemed to be some commotion at the front. I went to check what it was all about.
“We already booked for 35 persons online. You guys should check your system well and don’t waste our time,” Emmy was saying. There were some angry words from some other boys.
“I have to double-check that. You guys have to wait,” the security guard at the gate replied. He raised a hand and went inside the security room.
“Okay, it has been cleared. I’m sorry for the delay. However, only one of you is expected.”
“What is that supposed to mean? Is this a silly joke? Are you guys messing with us?” It was one of our troublesome boys in class. I did not know his name, but he had a reputation for violence in school.
The guard looked across us, seeming to scan our faces. He then stopped, looking straight in my direction.
“Only one of you is expected,” he repeated. It felt as though he was looking straight at me this time. It was weird, and I wanted to say something, but I was like a statue.
“I’m sorry, you all can go in.” The moment snapped like an overstretched cord, jarring me back into place. I could see the classmate who had spoken earlier being held back a couple of feet from the guard.
As the gate opened and we all walked in, he was still raining expletives at the guard. My limbs still felt stiff from the earlier inertia, though, so I just kept walking on muscle memory rather than will. Suddenly, a cold hand stretched out and touched my arm. I jumped.
“Hey, are you okay?”
It was Darrel. I tried to comport myself and gave an unconvincing smile.
“I’m fine,” I murmured and locked my arms with his without thinking as we went.
Immediately, I was scared I had misstepped. I looked at him sharply and half-untangled my arm, but he just looked back at me, surprised. He smiled and kept on going, so I was emboldened and kept our arms locked.
We were supposed to tour the site immediately, but we were told that the tour guide who handled group tours had stepped out just a while ago. We were asked whether we would wait by the fountain until she was back or take a personal tour instead. We chose to wait.
Everyone formed small groups around the fountain, chatting animatedly, eating and goofing around. I looked around for Jennifer and found her standing at a corner with Emmy, laughing at some joke. I knew she had a huge crush on Emmy, so that lessened my guilt.
Darrel and I moved closer to the fountain, chatting about the beauty of art. The fountain sent droplets of water at intervals at us as we talked, but I could scarcely feel them. It was a picturesque moment for me, facing each other, holding hands, and feeling like no one else existed in the world.
We drew closer, so dangerously close that I could feel his breath. Bells rang in my head that we were in a public place, but they sounded a thousand miles away.
Suddenly, a strong wind blew our way, blasting us with the fountain water. No one on our side of the fountain was untouched, but we wannabe art critics cum lovebirds standing at the edge got wetter than everyone else. I spent a moment trying to get water off my face and hair, embarrassed by all the laughs and catcalls that came our way.
“Sorry for the delay, guys. I’m here.” It was the tour guide. Everyone turned to her, and that took the attention away from us. Darrel whispered that she was sent by the ancient gods of the land to save an Egba daughter in distress. I barely managed to contain my laughter.
I rolled my eyes as she told us, History students, the story of how Olumo Rock was significant to the Egba as a fortress, as well as a cultural and religious symbol and centre. She had a storyteller’s voice, though, so I did not mind it.
We began to climb the rock, carefully navigating the narrowly hewn path up it. The air felt cool and fresh, perfumed with the smell of wet rocks and the Panseke trees standing proudly alongside the pathway. Elated hoots and fearful screeches from our group interjected our ascent.
My feet tingled the moment we started climbing. I began to feel a sense of déjà vu the further we went. I would have thought that my father had probably brought me here when I was a kid, except that he had always said that he had never brought me to Abeokuta.
The feeling grew stronger when we got closer to the cave settlements. I gripped Darrel’s hand tighter. Someone asked if the caves were safe to enter. The tour guide answered that some were, while others were not. Someone else asked if we were going to explore any, but she replied in the negative, explaining that it was not advisable for a big group to explore the caves.
I could hear the conversations around me, but my mind was somewhere else, in a time when I knew everywhere in the caves. Unconsciously, I jerked at Darrel’s arm, and the ring he had been twirling in his hand fell and rolled into a nearby cave.
I hastily apologised.
He didn’t say anything for a minute. “That was my mum’s. She gave it to me just before she…” He paused. “I need to get it back.”
“Let’s tell the tour guide.”
“No!” He got himself together before continuing. “You don’t understand. I can’t lose that ring. What if she says it’s unsafe to enter? It couldn’t have rolled in far. I’ll just slip in and out in a minute.”
“Definitely not. We’re going in together.”
He looked like he wanted to argue, but I just pulled him gently and took a last look around to see that no one had noticed us trying to slink off at the back of the group. Everyone’s eyes were firmly ahead.
Then we went into the cave.
It was dark. It was black. It was black so thick I could almost touch it. I could not see my own hands in front of me. I could not see Darrel beside me. I looked behind me, and I could see the entrance we came in through, but it looked as though the entrance rejected light from entering. If I had not been holding Darrel as we entered, I probably would have had a panic attack immediately.
“Can you see it?” I asked softly, mostly to hide the tremor in my voice.
“I can’t see my own fingers. I’m trying to bring out my phone and switch on the torch.” His voice was as soft and quiet as mine. The darkness didn’t seem like a place to talk out loud, in any case. Who could tell what could be roused in an unknown dark cave?
The phone’s torchlight was not strong enough to dispel the darkness, but it pushed it back a bit, and our eyes tried to acclimatise to the darkness.
We went down and tried to feel around and move in random directions as we looked for the ring, but we could not find it. We moved forward carefully and checked back in the direction of the entrance so as not to lose track of it.
We lost track of it, though. We also lost track of time; it could have been five minutes or an hour that we had spent searching, but we were no longer checking when we saw a glint ahead.
“That could be it. Let’s go check,” he whispered, pulling me forward.
I was wary, especially as my feet started tingling strongly. The tingle had faded so much that I had stopped feeling it, but it came back so strongly that I stumbled.
Darrel barely noticed, though. He just kept pulling forward, and hand in hand, we went.
“You came.”
“What?” I asked Darrel.
“I didn’t say anything.”
I almost concluded that my fear was playing tricks on my mind when the voice came again, a bit louder this time.
“You came. You kept your promise.” This time, when I looked at Darrel, I could see that he heard it too.
We looked for the source of the voice. There was no one ahead, just the glint ahead, which was, in fact, a low-hanging fire lamp hung on the cave wall. Beside it was a tattered lump of clothes.
When the voice came again, it was from the lump of clothes.
“I have waited for so long. I never doubted you, though. You said you were going to be back. You took your sweet time, though, but it doesn’t matter now that you’re back.”
I didn’t understand what was happening. My mind was shutting down, collapsing on itself, trying to make sense of the words, but nothing made sense.
“Who are you? What are you?” Darrel’s voice sounded so far away that I could barely hear it, but I could still hear the fear in it. “We are about to leave, so, Simi, let’s go…”
“I don’t know you. But I know her. I can smell her blood. It’s him reborn. I am Ogundipe, the first captain of Adagba. When we were routed in the first Egba war, I took Adagba’s wife and children up the mountain, met with Adagba in here, and here he petitioned the god Esu, who told him to sacrifice someone he loves to him to win the war.”
“He didn’t want to sacrifice his family, so he decided to sacrifice me instead. However, he promised that if he won the war, he would come back and sacrifice someone else he loved so my spirit could be released to rest from the grip of Esu.
“The war has been won, and it’s been months, then years, decades and even centuries of my spirit roaming without rest as the will of Esu, but finally you’re back. With someone you loved. As promised.”
The darkness went darker and darker, seeming to become material as it came in closer, closing in on me and choking me, and I screamed.
And I screamed again.
Louder this time. Or maybe I just thought so.
I woke up in a hospital. I saw Jennifer sitting beside me, her face a swirl-pool of emotion. She tried to smooth out the creases on her face, and the telltale signs of tears dried out. She held my hand and asked me how I felt. I mumbled a reply and tried to ask after Darrel, but the words were like a sticky morsel of fufu stuck in my throat. My dad came in, so I tried to turn away. I could not look him in the eye after what I had done, so I shut my eyes tightly and prayed the darkness would take me. It did.
“Humans just run, but they can never outrun destiny” is another of my father’s favourite sayings. When I came to, I faced my fears and found answers, and it changed me permanently. Jennifer told me I was found on the second day at the entrance of a cave, a place they had walked past several times throughout that day while searching for Darrel and me.
Darrel was never found. I was asked several questions about what had happened, whether I had walked into a cave or walked out of one when I was found, but I couldn’t answer any questions.
I missed my final papers. I miss Darrel. I miss the girl I was, who would have been cartwheeling over Jennifer and Emmy being in love. I hate how hollow my dad’s words of encouragement sounded to me, especially when he could not clearly answer if he knew about that family lore.
But I tried to move on. I tried. But I was tied to that cave. To Darrel’s spirit still roving there, and the young lady that was me, who never left, even though I know I never could. Or that I never would.
Yesterday, I went on a first date for the first time in years, and I was asked to say something about myself.
“My name is Simi, and in my family we keep our promises.”