Fiction · Horror
From Penned: September 2026Outstanding
Before Dawn
By Epiphany · 24 min read
Not rated yet
I woke before the call to prayer, though for a few seconds I did not know where I was.
I’ve heard that there are dreams that disappear the moment you open your eyes, retreating quickly and leaving behind only the faint impression that something has happened to you, though you cannot say what.
This was not one of those dreams.
I lay still beneath the sheet, listening to the ceiling fan make its tired clicking sound. Somewhere outside, a dog barked once and fell silent. The house was otherwise quiet, the particular quiet of the hours before morning properly began.
Then I remembered the dream. Trees. The smell of food. Young voices laughing somewhere beyond me. Music from a small cassette player. And a voice counting.
One.
Two.
Three.
The voice was that of a young woman. I had not heard it in more than forty years.
“Grandpa?”
My granddaughter stood at the bedroom door in an oversized T-shirt, her face still creased by sleep.
“Why are you awake?”
I looked at the clock. 5:17.
“I don’t know.”
She came closer. She said I had been talking, then shouting. I laughed and told her I must have been arguing with someone.
“Who?”
I looked towards the window. For a moment I could see them again: young bodies beneath trees, a girl in a light-coloured dress, someone bending over a cassette player, the green of leaves in late afternoon —and her.
“I had a dream,” I told her.
“About what?”
I almost told her. Instead, I said, “University.”
She looked disappointed. Then she left to tell her mother I was awake.
She was eight that year, already losing her milk teeth… already certain that every strange thing I said could be explained if she just asked enough questions. I loved that about her. I was not ready to be the strange thing she couldn’t explain.
I remained in bed. The house was beginning to wake around me. A tap opened. A door closed. A chair scraped against the floor. Ordinary sounds. The small machinery of another ordinary morning.
I listened to them and thought about the picnic.
It had been forty-three years ago. Perhaps forty-four. I have never been very good with the arithmetic of that particular memory.
What I remember clearly is that I was twenty-three, a student at the University of Ibadan, and I did not want to go.
There was a girl, of course. There is always a girl when a man tells a story like this, though I should say at once that she was not the reason I remember it.
At least, that is what I told myself for many years.
The University of Ibadan had a way of making you feel older than you were. Perhaps it was the buildings. Perhaps it was the trees. Or perhaps it was simply that most of us had come from homes where university was spoken about with such seriousness that it sounded like the beginning of adulthood.
I had been there long enough to know which lecturers could be approached after class, which ones preferred to be left alone, where to get a decent plate of rice when money was short, and which friends could be trusted with borrowed notes.
I also knew that I disliked picnics.
Our course representative announced ours after a Friday lecture. He stood before the class with a sheet of paper and the confidence of a man addressing a very small parliament.
We were going to Agodi Gardens.
The complaints began immediately. Who would pay? Why did we need an outing? Was the department contributing? Could the money not be used for something more sensible?
The course representative ignored all of it. We had spent three years seeing one another in class, he said. We should spend one afternoon seeing one another outside class.
I remember looking across the room at her. She was sitting two rows ahead, writing in a notebook. She had a habit of tilting her head slightly whenever she concentrated, as though she were listening to something beneath the noise around her.
I had admired her for almost two years.
Admiration is an easy thing when you are young. It asks very little of you. You can keep it to yourself, feed it with glances and small observations, and never have to discover whether the person you admire would have any interest in knowing you properly.
We spoke, of course. We were classmates. We had borrowed notes from one another. Once, she corrected something I said during a seminar, and I spent the rest of the afternoon pretending not to be embarrassed.
She laughed. I wondered for days whether she had been laughing with me or at me. That was the sort of problem that seemed important at twenty-three.
My friend found me outside the faculty building after the announcement.
“You are coming.”
“I have not said so.”
He laughed. “She is going.”
“I know.”
“I did not say her name.”
He did not need to.
I paid one naira fifty kobo the following morning.
On the day of the picnic, I found myself thinking less about Agodi Gardens than about the girl who would be sitting somewhere on the bus. I had even rehearsed what I might say to her. Nothing clever. Just enough to begin a conversation that had nothing to do with lectures, assignments or examinations. Something ordinary. Something that might allow us, for an hour or two, to become people rather than classmates.
The bus was waiting outside the faculty building when I arrived. It was an old Peugeot, white once, though years of dust had given it a colour of its own. Its windows were open. Its metal body was already warm beneath the morning sun.
People climbed aboard carrying bags, food wrapped in cloth and newspaper, bottles of soft drink and a transistor radio.
Someone had brought a cassette player with spare batteries, already playing Prince Nico Mbarga on a loop.
The course representative counted us.
One. Two. Three.
He counted again before we left. Twenty-three. He looked at the list, then at us.
“Are we complete?”
Someone said yes.
I remember finding the question strange. There were twenty-three of us. Or twenty-four. I have gone over the number many times since then. At twenty-three, I would not have understood why a number should matter.
I walked in last.
Then I saw her. She was sitting beside the window with her notebook on her lap. There was an empty seat beside her.
She moved her bag.
I took the seat.
The bus pulled away from the university. For a while, everyone talked. I watched Ibadan pass through the open window: shopkeepers lifting shutters near Dugbe, women arranging vegetables, buses stopping where they pleased, pedestrians crossing roads as if traffic were a private negotiation between them and God. The country was already learning to live with shortages and uncertainty, though at twenty-three, we mostly experienced them as inconveniences. We noticed queues before we understood economics. We noticed arguments before we understood politics. We listened to the radio and then went to class.
That morning, however, the ordinary world seemed unusually close to me.
She sat beside me with her notebook closed. Every so often, she looked out of the window, and I caught myself studying her reflection in the glass.
I remember the small scar near her wrist. I remember the way she tucked her hair behind one ear when the bus became warm. I remember that she laughed once when someone at the back began singing badly. And I remember thinking that, if the day went well, I would ask her to walk with me after we returned to campus.
It was a small plan. I had no idea how much of my life would later gather around that afternoon.
She smiled at something outside the window. I asked whether she had been to Agodi before.
Many times, she said.
I asked whether she liked it.
“It is alright.”
Only alright?
She looked at me as though I had asked a ridiculous question. Then she said something I have remembered ever since.
“I am surprised you came.”
I asked why.
“You don’t like these things.”
I smiled. “You know me that well?”
She looked at me.
“I know you better than you think.”
There was something strange in the certainty of it. Before I could ask what she meant, the bus turned onto another road. The buildings thinned. Trees became thicker. The sound of the city faded behind us.
She stopped smiling.
“Do you remember the accident?”
I believed I knew which accident she meant. A student had died in our second year, or so I had come to remember it. There had been a funeral. For weeks, it was all anyone talked about.
“I remember,” I said.
“Everything?”
“Why are you asking me this?”
She looked through the window.
“Forget it.”
I should have pressed her. I didn’t.
Agodi Gardens was busy when we arrived. Families moved along the paths. Children ran ahead of their parents. Somewhere nearby, water moved over rocks.
For a few minutes, everything seemed ordinary. More than ordinary. Pleasant.
We spread a cloth beneath some trees and arranged the food. Rice, fried meat, bread, oranges, soft drinks and tea appeared from different bags until the cloth looked like a small celebration.
She caught me watching the food being arranged and smiled.
“You didn’t want to come,” she said.
“I never said that.”
“You didn’t have to.”
I reminded her that she had once corrected me in front of the whole class, and that I had never fully forgiven her for it.
She laughed, the same unguarded laugh from the bus, and told me I had deserved it: I had been insufferably confident that day, and someone had needed to say so.
For a while, we simply sat there. The afternoon settled around us: fried meat, someone tuning a radio, children shrieking near the water. She passed me an orange and laughed when I struggled to peel it without breaking the skin.
The course representative, suddenly anxious about responsibility, told us nobody should go anywhere alone and that we would leave before sunset.
Nobody paid much attention.
I looked towards the trees. She was standing apart from the others, staring into the branches. I followed her gaze. There was nothing unusual there.
She turned to me.
“Come. I want to show you something.”
We walked a short distance from the others to a low stone wall. She opened her notebook. The page was blank.
“I want to ask you something,” she said.
“Do you remember the girl who died in our second year?”
“I remember.”
“What do you remember?”
“She was quiet… Serious. She sat near the window during lectures.” I paused.
“She had a brother, I think.”
The girl beside me looked at me.
“She didn’t.”
I laughed. “I remember that she did.”
“You don’t.”
The wind moved through the trees. Somewhere behind us, our classmates called that the food was ready. When I looked back at her, she was watching me with an expression I could not understand.
“You really don’t remember, do you?”
Before I could answer, she looked past me. I turned. Nobody was there. Only trees.
She caught my arm.
“Don’t.”
“What?”
“Don’t look.”
She said she thought she had seen someone. We returned to the others. I tried to forget the conversation. For a while, I succeeded.
There was food. There was laughter. Someone produced a camera. We gathered beneath the trees for a group photograph. I found myself standing beside her. Our shoulders touched.
She looked at me. “Don’t look behind you.”
The camera flashed.
From somewhere beyond the trees came a voice.
One. A pause. Two. Another pause. Three. Then silence.
Nobody reacted. No one except me.
I looked at her. Her face had gone completely still.
“You heard it,” she said.
“Heard what?”
She shook her head. “Nothing.”
I told myself the counting had come from children playing somewhere in the gardens. That explanation should have been enough. It wasn’t.
An hour later, the course representative suggested we go further into the gardens. Beyond the trees, he said, stood an old enclosure no longer in use. Final-year students used to go there for one last photograph before leaving university. He wanted us to take ours there and carve our names into the tree as a joke. “One last mark before we scatter,” he said.
The suggestion unsettled me. I said I would not go. For once, nobody laughed at my refusal; they simply gathered their things and started down the path, as if the decision had already been made. Even she went with them. I could have stayed behind, but the thought of being left alone beneath those trees was worse. I followed last.
She went very still.
“You knew about this place,” I said.
“No.”
“You don’t look surprised.”
She smiled faintly. “You notice too much.”
We followed the narrow path. The ordinary sounds of the gardens disappeared behind us. Even the conversations became quieter. Nobody told us to lower our voices. We simply did.
After a while, she stopped.
“Do you remember the day she died?”
“Yes.”
“Where were you?”
“On campus.”
“No.” She said it so simply that I almost laughed. “You weren’t on campus.”
“Where was I?”
She looked towards the trees. “Here.”
A few minutes later, we reached the enclosure. There was a rusted gate half-covered by vegetation. The course representative pushed it open.
Beyond it stood a clearing. And in the middle of the clearing stood a tree.
I knew that tree. I did not know how. The recognition came before the memory.
The smell of wet iron from the gate. A sound. A face. A hand. A voice saying my name.
Then the memory broke through. I had been there before. Not at twenty-three. Much earlier. There had been fewer people. Someone was crying. Someone was counting.
One. Two. Three.
Then a fourth voice came from behind the gate.
“Four.”
Nobody moved. We stood there until the course representative told everyone to leave. We quickly returned to the main area.
I don’t remember the walk back clearly, only that my mind was still at the gate, replaying that fourth voice. It was minutes later, back among the others, that I realized I could not say when she had stopped walking beside me.
I counted the people around the cloth. Twenty-three. I asked where she was. Nobody understood the question.
The course representative looked at me.
“What girl?”
For several seconds, I thought he was joking. Then I looked around. Twenty-three faces. The empty place beside the cloth. Her notebook.
I picked it up. The first pages were blank. Then, in the middle, I found three words written in handwriting I recognised.
You forgot again.
Beneath them was the date of the accident. And beneath the date was my name.
I stared at the notebook. The course representative looked from it to my face. His confusion gave way to concern, but he did not seem to recognise the girl I was describing.
I insisted we search. They came with me, not because they remembered her, but because they could see I was frightened. I called her name again and again. Beside me, the others searched for someone they could no longer describe.
Eventually, I returned to the old enclosure with another student. The tree stood in the clearing. Something had been carved into its bark. Her name. The letters looked old. Older than that afternoon. Beneath the tree, the earth had been disturbed.
We stood there until an elderly man appeared through the trees. He wore a groundsman’s faded overalls, and there was a cutlass hanging loosely from one hand, the look of a man who had spent decades among those trees.
He looked at us without surprise.
“You people should not be here.”
We told him we were looking for our friend. He asked her name. When I gave it, his face changed. Only slightly. But I saw it.
“How long has she been with you?” he asked.
“Since this morning.”
He shook his head. “Impossible.”
“Why?”
He looked towards the tree.
“That girl has been gone for three years now,” he said. “Feels longer. This place does that to a man.”
I laughed, a short, ugly sound that surprised me. I wanted to take it back as soon as I heard it.
The old man looked at me.
“Do you remember the accident?”
The question seemed to open something inside my head. A corridor. White walls. The smell of medicine. A girl’s hand gripping mine.
I heard myself say yes.
The old man shook his head.
“Na so some memory be… e go still dey alive, even after the person wey get am don go.”
Then he walked away.
I opened the notebook. “You forgot again” was still there. Beneath it was another sentence.
You were supposed to die with her.
The journey back to the university was quiet. The cassette player had gone silent because the batteries had finally given up. I sat by the window. The seat beside me was empty. I kept looking at it.
At the university, everyone dispersed as if nothing unusual had happened. Someone close to me asked, quite cheerfully, whether I’d enjoyed myself, and nodded without really listening to my answer.
I returned to my room and opened the notebook. The pages were blank. The sentence was gone. So was the date. So was my name.
For several days, I convinced myself I had imagined everything.
Then I went home.
My mother was sorting through an old cupboard when I found a photograph album. The first pages contained photographs of my childhood. Then secondary school. Then university.
I turned another page.
There, beneath a tree I somehow recognised, stood five people. I knew three of them at once: myself, younger and thinner than I remembered being; the old man, though his hair had still been dark; and, beside me, unmistakably, the girl. She was looking directly at the camera. Not smiling. She could not have been alive for this photograph. I knew that even then, and some part of me simply refused to find it strange.
I knew her. Not from the picnic. From somewhere much earlier.
The other two figures stood slightly apart, half turned away, their faces never quite resolving, no matter how long I looked at them.
On the back, in my mother’s handwriting, was a note.
She always dated things, even photographs. Beneath the date, she had written: First year. After the accident.
Below the date, in smaller writing, as though added at a different time:
“He came back alone.”
And fainter still, almost rubbed away:
“But he was not the same one who left.”
I asked my mother about her. She became quiet. For a while, she continued sorting the papers in front of her, though it was obvious she was no longer reading any of them. My mother was not a woman who enjoyed unnecessary explanations. When something troubled her, she became quieter rather than more talkative.
Eventually, she told me that the girl had been one of my closest friends during our first year. She had visited our house. My mother remembered her.
The admiration I had nursed for two years, the safe, distant admiration I had described to myself so carefully, had not been admiration at all. It had been grief. I had mistaken the ache of missing someone for the thrill of wanting her.
Then my mother told me something I had never known. I had been unconscious for several days after an accident in my first year. I had remembered none of it.
I asked what happened. My mother said there were some things I had not been ready to remember.
“Who was with me?”
She did not answer.
Outside, a neighbour called to someone across the compound. A spoon struck the side of a metal pot in the kitchen. Ordinary sounds again, the kind that make a difficult conversation feel almost impossible.
Then my mother said, “You were not supposed to come home alone.”
I waited for her to explain. She did not. Her silence felt like both refusal and fear.
I asked whether the girl had died in the accident.
My mother looked at me for a long time.
“Go and rest,” she said. Her hand closed around mine, hard enough to hurt. Her eyes were bright with tears she would not let fall.
That was the end of the conversation. Or what passed for an end.
That evening, I found a hospital discharge note beneath the album. My name was at the top. The date was from my first year.
I had always placed the accident in our second year. I know now it belonged to the first. I would have been twenty then, barely settled into university, not yet the confident final-year student who complained about picnics.
The note described a prolonged loss of consciousness following a traumatic incident.
I read the words again. Prolonged loss of consciousness. Days, not hours. Not one night. Days.
Then the memory came back in pieces.
Rain. A road. A vehicle lying at an angle. The smell of petrol. Glass bright on the tarmac. Water rising past my ankles. Her hand, cold and wet, clutching mine. I had been on my knees beside her, trying to pull her towards me. I kept telling her to hold on. Her fingers tightened once, then slipped. I remember closing my own hand around nothing and refusing to open it. Someone was counting.
Someone was counting.
One. Two. Three.
The paper slipped from my fingers. I was back in that rain, on my knees, with my hand still closed around hers —or the memory of it. I had to force my fingers open one by one.
The picnic had not made the memory. It had brought me close enough to it that I could no longer keep it buried.
A week later, I returned to Agodi alone. I found the old enclosure. The gate was still there. The tree was still there. The name carved into the bark was gone. At the base of the tree, however, the earth was loose.
I knelt and dug with my hands.
I found a small wristwatch. The glass was cracked. The hands had stopped at 5:17.
I knew the watch. It had been mine.
The memory settled into place. The accident had happened near the gardens. She had been with me. She had died before help arrived. I had survived. I could not remember how I had let go of her hand, only that I had left that road without her.
I remained beneath the tree until the light began to fade.
Then the old man returned.
“I don dey work this ground,” he said, “before they born two of you.”
Before I could ask how he had found me, “I was the one who found the two of you, that morning, after the rain,” he continued.
He did not tell me anything I had not already pieced together from the album and the discharge note. He told me only one thing I did not know: how it happened. He told me he had found both of us after the rain. I had kept asking for her long after she could no longer answer. It was the sound of my own asking, he said, that frightened the people trying to help us.
I wanted to know why. He did not answer. Instead, he looked at the watch. Its hands moved, one minute and then another. I watched without speaking.
The old man told me to go home. So I did, and never saw him again.
That night, I placed the watch beside the photograph.
The counting returned to me.
One. Two. Three. Four. Five.
I thought I understood then that the counting had something to do with those who returned. I could not have said more than that.
Life continued. I finished university. I found work. I got married and had children. My mother grew older and died without ever fully explaining what she knew.
I kept the photograph and the watch. I never showed them to anyone.
I tried to explain what had happened at Agodi as the consequence of trauma. Perhaps the old man knew more about the accident than he admitted. Perhaps the counting had been a children’s game among the trees. I preferred these explanations because they asked nothing more of me.
There were many explanations. I preferred all of them.
What I could not stop recalling were the moments around the accident: the girl asking whether I remembered, the empty seat on the bus, the course representative counting us, the notebook, the watch. And always the counting.
One. Two. Three. Four. Five.
For decades, I believed five was the number of survival. I no longer know whether I was right.
Forty-three years after that afternoon at Agodi Gardens, I continue to wake before dawn from recurring dreams I do not fully remember.
The ceiling fan was turning. The house was quiet. Someone was counting. And then the voice stopped. It called my name. Once.
The room became quiet.
My granddaughter appeared at the bedroom door.
“Grandpa?”
She looked exactly as she had in the dream. Oversized shirt. Sleep in her eyes. One hand against the doorframe.
I looked towards the small table beside my bed. The photograph was there. I had not put it there. It had been in an envelope in the bottom drawer of my study for years.
I reached for it. My granddaughter watched me.
I turned it over. The photograph had changed. There were six people beneath the tree now, not five. I recognised myself, the girl, the old man, and the two figures I had never been able to name. And, standing slightly apart from the rest, wearing the same oversized T-shirt she had on now… my granddaughter.
“What is it?” she asked.
I could not answer.
On the back, in my mother’s handwriting, were four words.
You remembered too late.
My granddaughter leaned closer. “Who are they?”
I looked again. The girl was smiling. Not at the camera. At me.
And suddenly I understood what I had spent most of my life avoiding. The accident had never been the thing I was meant to remember. It was the reason I had forgotten. Even now, I cannot make myself say her name aloud. I have tried. My voice simply will not do it.
My granddaughter touched my arm.
“Grandpa?”
I wanted to reassure her, to tell her there was nothing to fear. But I remembered my mother’s hand gripping mine, her tears, and the warning she could not bring herself to explain.
Some things are better left alone.
I placed the photograph face down on the table.
“Nothing.”
The word came too easily.
Outside, the first call to prayer began. The darkness beyond the curtains had started to thin. Morning was coming.
My granddaughter opened the door. Before she left, she looked back at me. For a moment, I thought she was about to say something. Instead, she smiled faintly and walked away.
I waited until her footsteps disappeared. Then I looked at the photograph. The ceiling fan continued its slow rotation. One turn. Then another. The house was coming alive.
And from somewhere beyond the walls, so faintly that I almost convinced myself I had imagined it, I heard a young woman’s voice.
Counting.
One. Two. Three. Four. Five.
Then a pause. Long enough for me to realise what I had never understood at twenty-three.
She had not been counting the people who came with us.
She had been counting the people who came back.
I closed my eyes.
And waited for six.